Tix Frequently Asked Questions

Legal Issues

[L.1] Is Tix free software?

ANSWER: Tix is distributed under the same license as Tcl/Tk (a.k.a. BSD style license). Application developers can freely redistribute Tix along with their products.

General Questions About Using The Tix Library

[G.1] What does the "-disablecallback" option do?

ANSWER: Many Tix widgets have both a -value option and a -command option. Any modification of the -value will cause the -command callback to be executed. Sometimes this is undesirable. For example, calling "config -value" inside the callback procedure will cause the callback to be re-entered and thus an infinite recursion.

The -disablecallback can be used to advoid this problem. When this option is set, the -command callback will not be executed even if the -value of a widget is changed. Therefore, if you need to modify the -value of a widget inside its callback, do this:

    proc my_callback {w} {
	$w config -disablecallback true
	$w config value blah
	$w config -disablecallback false
If you find this too troublesome, you can call the command tixSetSilent:
    proc my_callback {w} {
	tixSetSilent $w blah

[G.2] How do I set the width of the entry subwidget inside the tixControl widget?

ANSWER: You can use the option database or the -options flag to set the configuration options of the subwidgets. E.g:

option add *TixControl*entry.width 10
tixControl .c -options {
   entry.width  10

[G.6] I am not using the tixForm geometry manager, but it is giving me errors about TixForm. What happened?

ANSWER: When you get error messages like this:
 (TixForm) Error:Trying to use more than one geometry
           manager for the same master window.
           Giving up after 50 iterations.
Most likely, the problem is when using tixLabelFrame widgets, you packed to the wrong frame:

This is WRONG:

   tixLabelFrame .d
        button .d.b
        pack .d.b 
This is the correct way:
   tixLabelFrame .d
        set f [.d subwidget frame]
        button $f.b
        pack $f.b
        pack .d 
Remember you don't pack directly into a TixLabelFrame widget. Instead, you should pack into its frame subwidget.

[G.7] How do I generate the tclIndex file for Tix?

ANSWER: Tix tclIndex files cannot be generated using the standard auto_mkindex procedure. You must use the tixindex program in the tools/ subdirectory in the Tix distribution. The syntax is
 tixindex *.tcl

[G.8] Can I ignore the default arguments passed by the various -command and -browsecmd options?

ANSWER: You can use the tixBreak command. For example:
 tixFileSelectDialog .c -command "puts foo; tixBreak" 

[G.9] What does tixWidgetDoWhenIdle do?

ANSWER: It does the same thing as tixDoWhileIdle (and "after -idle"). The difference is it takes its second argument as the name of a widget and executes this command only if the widget exists: i.e.:
  tixWidgetDoWhenIdle tixComboBox::Update $w blah blah ..
will execute tixComboBox::Update only if $w exists. $w may be destroyed after tixWidgetDoWhenIdle is called but before an idle event happens.

[G.10] Why isn't such a feature in Tix? Will it be implemented?

ANSWER: Generally requests for new features are welcomed. You can submit your requests to http://tix.sourceforge.net and we'll be happy to hear from you.

We can't guarantee to implement the requested features immediately. Usually it depends on how important the features. If the feature is requested by more people, it will usually get done faster. However, some frequently requested features probably won't be imlemented. Usually these features are cosmetic changes and:

  • they do not add new capability to the widgets
  • they are not universally liked
  • they confuse the user.

Some examples are:

  • Different foreground and background colors for the NoteBook tabs: having a lot of colors may antagonize the users that are "color haters"; also, the different colors don't make it easier for the user to locate the desired tab.
  • Ring-binder metaphore for the NoteBook widget: a waste of screen real estate.
  • Rows of tabs for the NoteBook widget: the user may be confused when the rows of tabs are switched. If you need to have a lot of tabs for the notebook, use the ListNoteBook widget instead.

[G.11] Who are using Tix in their software?

ANSWER: See http://tix.sourceforge.net

[G.12] I am using a DirList widget. When the user clicks on an item, the procedure of my -browsecmd gets called twice. However, I just want it to be called once.

ANSWER: The -browsecmd procedure is triggered by three types of events: <1>, <ButtonRelease-1>, and <B1-Motion>. When the user clicks on an entry, a <1> and a <ButtonRelease-1> event will happen in rapid session, which causes your -browsecmd procedure to be called twice.

A crude fix for this problem is to ignore all the <ButtonRelease-1> events. You can find out the event that triggers the -browsecmd procedure by the tixEvent command. Here is an example:

    tixDirList .c -browsecmd Browse

    proc Browse {args} {
	if {[tixEvent type] == "<ButtonRelease-1>"} {
	# ....
However, the above solution is not perfect. For example, if the user clicks down the button at entry one, drags it over entries two and three and release it on top of entry three, the following events may be caused:

  1. <1> on entry one.
  2. <B1-Motion> on entry two.
  3. <ButtonRelease-1> on entry three.

Therefore, if you use the above method, the browse event on entry three will be lost!

To devise a better solution, it's better to understand the basic design conventions of a Tix-based GUI. Suppose we have a list of entries displayed in a listbox (or DirList, or HList). When the user clicks on an entry, the GUI usually responds by displaying a "detailed view" of the entry. For example, if we put a list of file names in a listbox, when the user clicks on a file name, we display the contents of the file in a text window. If the user then clicks on another file name, the text window will load in the contents of the new file.

Now what happens if the user clicks on the same entry twice? Do we reload the contents of the file into the text window? This is usually unnecessary, inefficient and probably not what the user wants to do. The Tix convention is, when the user clicks on the same entry again, the detail view is not updated. If the user wants to force an update (e.g, the user knows the file's contents has been changed and wants to see the new version), he or she can double-click on the entry and the application will respond by redisplaying the detail view (reloading the file).

To implement this policy, the Browse procedure should be modified as the following:

    proc Browse {args} {
	global currentView

	set ent [tixEvent value]
	if {$ent == $currentView} {
	    # We have already displayed the detailed view of $ent.
	} else {
	    set currentView $ent
	    DisplayDetail $ent

[G.13] I get an error "can't read data(-value): no such element in array" when I use the tixExFileSelectDialog.

ANSWER: If you use tixExFileSelectDialog like this:
	tixExFileSelectDialog .f -command foo

	foo {filename} {
	    destroy .f
	    do some other stuff ...
it will cause a Tcl error because the dialog assumes that it still exists after calling your command. This usually result in errors like this:
	can't read "data(-value)": no such element in array
	    while executing
	"set data(-selection) $data(-value)..."
	    (procedure "tixComboBox::SetValue" line 30)
This "feature" is built into many Tix widgets and can't be fixed easily. To work around the problem, never destroy widgets inside -command calls. Usually you should unmap toplevel windows instead. If you must destroy widgets, do it with an "after" command. For example, the foo procedure should be rewritten as:
	foo {filename} {
	    wm withdraw .f
	    do some other stuff ...

	    after idle {if [winfo exists .f] {destroy .f}}
Execute the "after" command at the very end of the -command. Otherwise the idle handler may be activated by some "update" calls.

Question About Porting to Specific Platforms/Software

[P.1] The configure script gave me strange errors.

ANSWER: The problem may be you have several operating systems sharing the same file system. Some people encounter error messages like this:
# ./configure --prefix=/usr/vendor/tcl
loading cache ./config.cache
checking for a BSD compatible install... /usr/bin/installbsd -c
checking for ranlib... ranlib
checking how to run the C preprocessor... cc -E
checking for unistd.h... ./configure[603]: "${ac_cv_header_$ac_safe+set}": bad
The problem is at line 2, configure loaded in ./config.cache, which may have been created by a different operating system, with settings only usuable for that operating system. To get around this, you should type
make distclean
make all

[P.5] Solaris 2.4: Filenames in FileSelectBox are chopped off.

ANSWER: Problem:
With Tix4.0a7 (and also with Tix4.0a6) on Solaris 2.4, when running the widget demo, in tixFileSelectBox, in the two scolling lists (for Files an Directories), some of the file and directory names have their first 2 letters chopped off. And some files are repeated.
Solution: tixwish has some conflicts with /usr/ucblib/libucb.so.1 and you should not link it tixwish (you don't need it). Here is a solution provided by Charles L Ditzel (charles@hanami.cyberspace.com):
To fix the problem I was having, all I did was:
   unsetenv LD_LIBRARY_PATH
   set my PATH to something basic like:
   removed config.cache
   make clean
and now it works!! Must have been something in my old PATH or LD_LIBRARY_PATH that was causing it to pick up /usr/ucblib/libucb.so.

[P.7] I get a coredump as soon as tixwish starts up.

ANSWER: Try to get a backtrace of the stack when the core dump happens (with a debugger, for example). If the core dump happens right inside the call to Tk_ConfigureWidget() inside the file tixInit.c, then the problem is because you compiled libtk.a and libtix.a with different versions of the Th header file tk.h. Delete all the .o files from the src directory of Tix, fix the Makefile so that now you can compile libtix.a with the same tk.h that you used to compile libtk.a.